Judgment tends to surface when the process runs out.
It shows up in the gaps. When the research points in a direction but doesn’t close the decision. When the roadmap says one thing and the sprint reality says another. When a PO needs a call to keep momentum and engineering needs a constraint to move at all.
Those moments rarely get labeled. They don’t feel like design work. They feel like pressure. A need to decide without full coverage.
Most of that work disappears afterward. It’s not in the deck. It’s not in the write-up. It ends up in defaults, sequencing, and exclusions. You notice it later, usually when you come back to the product and realize how much was decided without ever being declared.
The same kinds of decisions, made over and over, start to define how the product behaves. One reasonable call doesn’t change much. A series of them does.
Small decisions compound.
What started as a one-off becomes the way things are done. The product takes on a shape, not because it was specified, but because the same kind of choice kept getting made.
Tools help up to a point. Frameworks buy time. Process creates room for discussion. None of it removes the need to decide. At some point a constraint has to be real. A direction has to be chosen knowing it will close off other paths.
You can usually feel when judgment is missing. Work stays open longer than it should. Options keep multiplying. The same questions resurface sprint after sprint. It looks like thoroughness. It slows everything down. Someone still absorbs the uncertainty, and it’s rarely evenly shared.
What tends to hold up are decisions that still make sense later. Not because they were right in every detail, but because they acknowledged tradeoffs instead of deferring them. They were specific enough to guide what came next.
Over time, that kind of judgment becomes readable in the work itself. You don’t need a long explanation to understand why something is the way it is. The choices point back to a consistent way of seeing the problem.
That’s usually when it becomes clear how much of the product was shaped in moments that never looked important… because nobody had the time to stop and call them important.
☺
To be continued in…
Field Note — Authority ³
